On 10 September 2008, Lehman reported 11% “tier one” capital and very conservative “net leverage“. On 15 September 2008, Lehman declared bankruptcy.
Despite reported shareholder’s equity of $28.4B just prior to the bankruptcy, the net worth of the holding company in liquidation is estimated to be anywhere from negative $20B to $130B, implying a swing in value of between $50B and $160B. That is shocking. … The orderly liquidation of a well-capitalized financial holding company ought to yield something close to tangible net worth, which for Lehman would have been about $24B.
So Lehman misreported its net worth, right? Not according to the law. From the Valukas Report,
Section III.A.2: Valuation — Executive Summary:
“The Examiner did not find sufficient evidence to support a colorable claim for breach of fiduciary duty in connection with any of Lehman’s valuations.”
Steve Randy Waldman